This Too Shall Pass: A Traveller’s Inventory of Impermanence
Somehow, 91 springboard is empty, and so is Mango Meadows. There is a curious silence in places that are usually full of people, conversations, activity and the comforting chaos of shared existence.
There is something about these pauses. A kind of silent sorority. People come, people go, spaces fill up and empty themselves again. Even the familiar has a way of becoming unfamiliar.
This too shall pass.
And soon, the Serendipity Arts Festival will begin, and the quiet will give way to another season of activity.
It is Friday morning. My Friday ritual is to get indispired. I look for a profoundly ponder-able muse, usually from either Vartika Goyal or Matheikal. Today, Matheikal it is, and the prompt is: This too shall pass.
He wants to know whether it is escapism or consolation.
I find myself travelling a little further back, to a story from The Silk Route.
There is a traveller journeying through the desert, collecting memories and artefacts along the way. Each marketplace offers something to take home: objects, stories, encounters, fragments of lives that have crossed his path. He gathers these treasures as he makes his way through the landscape.
On his return journey, he passes through the same markets.
The markets are still there. The stalls are familiar. But the vendors are different. Younger faces have replaced the ones he remembers. The artefacts on display have changed. What was once precious and desirable has made way for something else.
The landscape is familiar, but nothing is quite the same.
The traveller has changed too. He carries memories of people who are no longer there, objects that may no longer have value, and experiences that cannot be recreated.
Perhaps that is what this too shall pass really means.
Not that everything disappears without consequence. Not that what we experience is insignificant. But that life is constantly moving, rearranging itself, replacing, renewing and transforming.
I visualize Lakshmi and her sister Alakshmi (Jyeshtha, if you prefer the formal introduction) playing a game of dice. As they move the pawns across the board, they might pause, look at each other and giggle: This too shall pass.
Despite being told that I have as much knowledge of Hindu mythology and scriptures as the pimple on the dimple of an ant’s left bum, and probably even less capacity to understand them, there are some things I do know. All right, I snoop. I find out. My friend, that is called research in the more respectable circles.
There is a Persian Sufi bard, Attar of Nishapur, associated with a story about a king who wanted a mystical ring. He wanted something that would make him happy when he was sad. The sages, fakirs and wise men eventually presented him with a ring engraved with the words This too shall pass.
When he was unhappy, it consoled him. When he was happy, it reminded him that happiness too was transient.
A rather inconvenient piece of jewellery, if you ask me. But perhaps that was the point.
The story has travelled through centuries, cultures and retellings. It appears in different literary traditions, including Deor’s Old English lament, where the misfortunes of others become reminders that suffering, however overwhelming, is not necessarily permanent. Later retellings and references, including those associated with Edward FitzGerald and Abraham Lincoln, have helped the phrase find its way into popular consciousness.
And here we are, centuries later, still asking the same question.
Is this too shall pass a consolation or an escape?
I think the answer depends on what we do with it.
When I was recovering from burns, there were moments when the pain seemed to occupy the entire universe. I learnt to recognise that a particularly intense wave of pain would last for a while and then subside. I could breathe through it, stay with it and allow it to run its course.
I was not escaping the pain. Nor was I pretending it did not exist. I was learning to experience it without allowing it to become the entirety of my reality.
That distinction has stayed with me.
Today, I see it less as a comforting phrase and more as an invitation to remain present. Pain passes, but so does pleasure. The difficult season passes, but so does the season we desperately want to hold on to. People change, relationships evolve, roles shift, and the spaces we once occupied become someone else’s familiar territory.
The danger is that we spend so much time resisting what is changing that we fail to experience what is happening.
Perhaps this is where the distinction between consolation and escapism lies. Consolation helps us stay with an experience without being consumed by it. Escapism encourages us to turn away from the experience altogether.
And there is another possibility.
What if this too shall pass is not simply about waiting for something to end? What if it is about recognising that we are participants in a process of becoming?
The traveller on the Silk Route cannot return to the same marketplace, even if he follows precisely the same road. The vendors have moved on. The objects have changed. His collection of memories has grown. He is no longer the person who first set out on the journey.
Perhaps the real artefact he has collected is not what he carries in his bags, but the person he has become along the way.
On pondering some more, another image emerges. That of a diligent quality-control department. Samples are being evaluated against an established gold standard. The evaluator examines each one and mutters, “This one shall pass.” Then another, “This too will pass.” And so on, with a few unfortunate samples that simply do not make the grade.
Life, I suspect, is a rather less efficient quality-control department. It doesn’t always tell us what is being tested, what the gold standard is, or whether we are supposed to pass at all.
Perhaps we are not samples waiting for approval. Perhaps we are works in progress.
And that brings me back to the traveller, the empty marketplace and the vendors who have moved on.
I no longer think this too shall pass is necessarily a reminder to endure until things get better. It is also a reminder not to cling too tightly when things are good, not to mistake a passing circumstance for a permanent identity, and not to confuse a particular chapter with the entire book.
We are not merely waiting for life to happen to us. We are continually being shaped by what we experience, what we choose, what we release and what we carry forward.
The markets will remain. The vendors will change. The artefacts will be replaced. The traveller will return, but never quite as the person who left.
And perhaps that is the most profound consolation of all.
This too shall pass. And so shall we. But not without being changed by the journey.
Penned for edition 248 of Indispire. #ThisTooWillPass
Originally written as part of the IndiBlogger / Indispire community conversation. With gratitude to IndiBlogger for providing the prompts, conversations and community that inspired these reflections.

Leave a Reply